Only if you have a specific plan to get the book into bookshops. Returns are what make a shop willing to stock an unknown title, but you pay for every copy that comes back. It is charged at the wholesale price on the date the return is processed, plus shipping and handling, which is more than you earned when that copy sold. Switching returns off does not end the exposure straight away either: you stay responsible for returns for 180 days afterwards. If no bookshop campaign depends on it, leave the book non-returnable.
Bookshops buy stock on the understanding that what does not sell can go back. A shop deciding whether to order an unknown indie title is weighing the risk of being left with copies it cannot shift. A returnable book removes that risk for the shop, so it improves the odds of being stocked.
That risk does not go away. It moves to you.
For wholesale distribution IngramSpark offers non-returnable, returnable and destroy, or returnable and deliver, chosen title by title.
Some orders ignore the setting. Direct and Global Connect print orders are non-returnable whatever you choose. IngramSpark can also require a title to be non-returnable, and a title it judges to breach the agreement is returnable whatever you set.
This is the part that catches authors out, and it follows from how IngramSpark pays.
When a copy sells, what you receive is list price, less wholesale discount, less print cost, less the market access fee. When that copy comes back, you are charged the wholesale price on the date the return is processed, plus shipping and handling.
The wholesale price is the list price less the discount. Your compensation had the print cost and the market access fee taken off as well. So the charge for a returned copy is larger than what you were paid for it, by roughly the print cost and the market access fee, before shipping and handling. You do not just give the sale back. Each return costs you money on top.
Two details make it worse:
Turning returns off stops the risk from growing, but it does not end it. You remain responsible for returns for 180 days after changing a title from returnable to non-returnable. That covers stock that shops ordered while the book was returnable.
Switching the other way carries its own risk. Making a title returnable can expose you to returns of copies of that ISBN that you never sold yourself.
Turn returns on when there is a reason that justifies the risk:
If none of that applies, non-returnable is the safer default. The book is still listed in Ingram's catalogue and can still be ordered.
Terms are quoted from the agreements as recorded in the AuthorAZ Publishing Database. Platform facts verified 4 September 2026.
Publishing Course
Publishing Database
Author Answer
Rights & Privacy